You are here

Does a Country’s Culture Influence the Use of Lean Production Systems?

Published on
08 December 2016

With globalization, companies have been forced to expand across borders. As a result, they have to check the validity of their management theories and tools when applied to various cultural contexts. Laurent Rannaz, president of Caterpillar France, shares with us his DBA findings on the subject of deploying lean tools. The study was carried out thanks to data collected from 80 Caterpillar factories in 17 countries from 2006 to 2010.

What were your research goals and how was the study carried out?

In the current global context, my goal was to analyze the deployment of lean production tools in each country in order to understand the impact of local culture on these processes. The goal of the study was not to help companies decide in which countries they should set up shop, but rather to help them understand which management principles could help mitigate cultural differences. The study analyzed Caterpillar Production System (CPS) scores for each factory in relation to cultural factors. I used Hofstede’s six national cultural dimensions (Power Distance (PDI), Individualism (IDV), Masculinity (MAS), Uncertainty Avoidance (UAI), Long Term Orientation (LTO) and Indulgence Versus Restraint (IVR)). 

The study results indicated a clear correlation between Hofstede's dimensions and the evolution of CPS scores. The results demonstrate that countries with high PDI and LTO as well as those with low IDV and IVR can expect better adoption of lean management tools. No influence was noted in terms of MAS and UAI. In addition, the study highlights a positive correlation between industrialization levels and lean-tool adoption.

Can you share with us some concrete examples?

For example, France is average in terms of the four indexes (PDI, LTO, IDV and IVR). In Grenoble, Caterpillar France’s headquarters, we implemented new production systems with a little bit of difficulty, but we believed in the change and all ended well. In the USA, and other anglo-saxon countries, an individualistic culture orientation can make it more difficult to implement production systems. In contrast, Japan and China are able to strongly mobilize everyone to implement shared objectives, which encourages the implementation of production systems.

In Russia, China and Mexico, PDI is highest. So this study helps evaluate the various difficulties you might encounter in relation to a country’s cultural characteristics. You can evaluate each situation tool by tool and country by country to predict reactions and challenges that might arise when implementing a production system.

How did this study contribute to Caterpillar’s development?

The results of this study supported pathways to improve efficiency within the company. Pilot study findings were presented at strategy meetings and shared with the Senior Vice President in charge of CPS. An executive summary of the findings was shared with company stakeholders, including managing directors worldwide. A seminar was organized to exchange ideas with corporate lean team in charge of production system scores deployment. The study provided concrete evidence to support the implementation of potential changes in manuals for production system scores.

Read the thesis summary

On the same subject

  • Projets intégratifs en entreprises : des dispositifs pédagogiques gagnant-gagnant
    Published on 17 September 2020

    Integrative company projects: a win-win educational model

    Companies with concrete operational and strategic challenges can benefit from the skills of GEM students. The integrative projects program enables a team of GEM students to explore, analyze and report their findings on a specific mission for a...

  • Projets intégratifs en entreprises : des dispositifs pédagogiques gagnant-gagnant
    Published on 17 September 2020

    Projets intégratifs en entreprises : des dispositifs pédagogiques gagnant-gagnant

    Les Projets intégratifs en entreprise, déployés par Grenoble Ecole de Management, intègrent les compétences d’un groupe d’étudiants au cœur d’une problématique opérationnelle ou stratégique d’entreprise.

  • La réforme de l’alternance : ce qui change pour les entreprises en 2020
    Published on 16 March 2020

    Changing work/study in France: new opportunities for businesses

    Work/study offers companies an interesting opportunity for recruitment. New work/study reforms in France offer business schools greater autonomy to meet company demands.

  • digitalisation du recrutement
    Published on 20 January 2020

    Digitalizing recruitment to facilitate human interactions

    Digital technology has revolutionized HR and recruitment. The ability to digitalize certain tasks opens the door to greater focus on opportunities for face to face interactions such as such as job interviews or recruitment forums.

  • Mashiyaneh Hatam Abadi
    Published on 18 November 2019

    A passion for knowledge and multiculturalism

    Mashiyaneh Hatam Abadi shares with us her passion for knowledge and multiculturalism. As Official DBA Ambassador for GEM, her diverse professional and educational background offers us a unique perspective on learning and fosters our thirst for...

  • Finance de demain : construire l’éthique des futurs leaders, avec les entreprises
    Published on 21 October 2019

    The future of finance: training ethical leaders with the support of business

    Using a variety of tools such as the serious game Finethics, Grenoble Ecole de Management and the network Finance de demain is encouraging professionals in the finance sector to question their practices and help shape an ethical future for finance.

  • Slobodan Velinov
    Published on 30 August 2019

    Testimonial: Teaching MBA classes after DBA graduation

    One inner question every DBA student asks himself during his doctoral journey is what career to pursue after finishing a DBA study. All those who are not yet established as professors and have strong business experience secretly think of pursuing an...

  • Published on 15 April 2019

    GEM juries: a great match for professionals

    Every year, the Grenoble Ecole de Management admissions and graduation juries rely upon the expertise of working professionals. Participate in this year’s GEM juries to identify, evaluate and understand the next generation of talent at Grenoble...

  • Margaux Raab et Hugo Avale, Fondateurs de neojobs
    Published on 25 February 2019

    Agility: the first key to entrepreneurship

    The co-founders of neojobs share first hand advice drawn from their startup experience. And behind all of their advice lies the importance of agility for any entrepreneurial project.

  • Les dynamiques de pouvoir dans le domaine du coaching
    Published on 24 January 2019

    The power dynamics in coaching

    Interpersonal relationships are a fundamental key to successful coaching. However, recent research highlights the importance of going beyond the coach-coachee relationship in order to consider triangular power relationships between coach, coachee...

  • Grenoble Ecole de Management étaye son offre de services corporate
    Published on 23 November 2018

    GEM: a catalyst for innovation

    Serious games, the first-year challenge, research chairs, a business lab… Innovation is at the heart of Grenoble Ecole de Management. The school offers students, researchers and businesses an environment to foster creativity and collaboration.

  • GEM lance le certificat RH de la transformation numérique
    Published on 15 October 2018

    HR is a key player in digital transformation

    The digital transformation is bringing important changes for individuals and organizations with a direct impact on HR. A new certificate at Grenoble Ecole de Management prepares HR professionals to adapt to the digital transformation and implement a...

  • A proud GEM graduate, Dr. Ahmad Anouti
    Published on 27 September 2018

    Testimonial: My DBA Journey

    Dr. Ahmad Anouti's Testimonial, a proud Grenoble Ecole de Management graduate.

  • Séverine Le Loarne
    Published on 12 July 2018

    GEM - Les Prem1ères: an incubator for female entrepreneurship

    The FERE Research Chair recently partnered with France’s leading incubator network to launch a mobile incubator aimed at supporting female entrepreneurship in rural areas. The first of its kind, this incubator offers a new approach to encourage...

  • Waël Sharafeddine
    Published on 24 May 2018

    Testimonial: Waël Sharafeddine's dissertation defense

    On the morning of Thursday 29 March 2018 in Grenoble, after a sleepless night and two days of intensive preparation for my DBA presentation with more than 30 rehearsals, the day I had been awaiting during the five years of my DBA research experience...

  • Comment rentabiliser une stratégie de marque employeur
    Published on 25 May 2018

    How to Improve the ROI of Your Employer Branding?

    Employer branding has become a key factor in the success of a company and a negative reputation can directly impact financial performance. How can you improve your employer branding strategy?

  • comment tester votre business model
    Published on 26 April 2018

    Startups: How to Test Your Business Model?

    Defining the right business model for an innovative product or service is essential to its success. Experimentation proves to be a useful tool for innovative startups to find the right model.

  • Olivier Blanc, GEM ESC 98
    Published on 26 April 2018

    Improving Your Recruitment Strategy: a Smart Investment

    The recruitment process can be costly and sometimes end in failure. Fine tuning your recruitment process will create concrete improvements in terms of company performance.

  • Published on 11 April 2018

    Comment accélérer la croissance des start-up ?

    Quels sont les mécanismes qui permettent d’évaluer le potentiel des entreprises high tech ? A partir des résultats d’une étude menée aux Etats-Unis avec John Stayton sur les accélérateurs d’entreprises, Vincent Mangematin présente trois méthodes d’...

  • Pourquoi les DRH doivent-elles se saisir du digital ?
    Published on 26 March 2018

    Why Is the Digital Revolution Essential for HR?

    The digital revolution is impacting all areas of business. While HR are particularly affected by this change, it’s an opportunity for them to focus their efforts on the “employee experience”.

  • Maya Mallat Yassine
    Published on 19 March 2018

    My DBA Survival Kit

    A fellow working mother recently wrote in a blog, “Mention 'work-family balance’ to a roomful of working women who have children, and the response you'll probably get is semi-hysterical laughter...followed by tired sighs.” Imagine being a mom of...

  • Published on 27 February 2018

    New MSc International HR Management in the digital age

    When Digital Systems are dramatically changing the way we work on a daily basis, Human Resources professionals have to adapt too. To that end, GEM continues to innovate and is now one of the first – if not the first – business school to introduce a...

  • Les conditions licites de la cybersurveillance du salarié
    Published on 25 January 2018

    Workplace Cyber Surveillance: Rights and Obligations

    Can a business spy on its employees? Yes, within certain limits. Discover how European courts regulate workplace cyber surveillance.

  • Les conditions licites de la cybersurveillance du salarié
    Published on 25 January 2018

    Cybersurveillance : Quels droits et obligations pour l’employeur (et réciproquement) ?

    La Cour européenne des droits de l’homme impose des limites au contrôle des communications électroniques par l’employeur, qui reste régi par chaque Etat membre.

  • Research: the impact of performance evaluations on an individual's network.
    Published on 19 December 2017

    How to Improve Employee Annual Evaluations?

    Stressful, childish, demotivating… The words used to describe annual evaluations are rarely positive. How can we change such a perspective?

  • Analogical Reasoning, Generating Innovative Ideas With Customers
    Published on 08 December 2017

    Research: Analogical Reasoning, Generating Innovative Ideas With the Help of Customers

    All innovation processes begin with the generation of new ideas, the majority of which end up not being useful. To improve this process, businesses are involving customers. However, the quality of ideas generated by customers is often quite...

  • Analogical Reasoning, Generating Innovative Ideas With Customers
    Published on 08 December 2017

    Recherche : Créativité des consommateurs, comment bien utiliser la pensée analogique ?

    Si vous demandez à des consommateurs d’être créatif en faisant des analogies, ils émettront beaucoup d’idées de produits ou de services. Mais si vous voulez de bonnes idées, il faut également tenir compte de leur niveau d’expertise afin de bien...

  • Diogo Hildebrand, researcher and Corporate Social Responsibility expert at Grenoble Ecole de Management
    Published on 17 November 2017

    Research: How Do Consumers Evaluate Corporate Social Responsibility?

    From fighting poverty and illness to providing disaster relief, corporations around the world dedicate considerable resources to corporate social responsibility (CSR). Contributions come in a variety of forms such as monetary donations, the donation...

  • Diogo Hildebrand, researcher and Corporate Social Responsibility expert at Grenoble Ecole de Management
    Published on 17 November 2017

    Recherche : De quelle manière les consommateurs évaluent-ils la Responsabilité Sociale des Entreprises (RSE) ?

    De la lutte contre la pauvreté et la maladie à l'aide aux sinistrés, les entreprises du monde entier consacrent des ressources considérables à leur politique RSE. Cela peut prendre différentes formes : dons en argent, dons de matériel ou bénévolat...

  • Bénédicte Tilloy, artiste et ex-DRH à la SNCF, a posté ses aquarelles sur Twitter, entrainant l’initiative Art Wagon, portée par un conducteur de trains
    Published on 13 September 2017

    Art: Bringing Emotion Back into Company Life

    Art is a gateway to emotions and offers an interesting approach to foster more humane relationships at work.

  • Research: How we take breaks can impact performance at work.
    Published on 12 September 2017

    Let Your Mind Wander at Work!

    It’s time to space out at work… Recent research suggests that mind-wandering has a positive impact on concentration!

  • Dominique Steiler propose de mettre l’entreprise au service de la cité
    Published on 14 September 2017

    If You Want Peace, Prepare for It

    Ready to evolve towards economic peace and well-being at work? Discover the experiences shared by partner companies and the latest research by the Mindfulness Chair.

  • STAGES : Un directeur de la Fnac raconte son expérience
    Published on 10 July 2017

    FNAC: an Internship to Discover First Hand the Challenges of Customer Relations

    A student internship during the month of December provides student and mentor with the chance to learn hands on.

  • Franck Rouault
    Published on 09 May 2017

    DBA: A guide to achieve your Doctorate

    Franck Rouault is a 2015 Grenoble Ecole de Management DBA graduate. He has co-written a book entitled "Doctrine- The Guide to achieve your Doctorate" with 4 other authors who are also DBA graduates. In this book, they share their experiences and...

  • Published on 17 November 2016

    Michelin Innovates Using Serious Games

    Michelin innove dans son approche de services de la mobilité grâce à l’open innovation, au serious Game "Tech It ! " et avec les étudiants de GEM.

  • Published on 17 November 2016

    Mobilité : comment Michelin innove

    Michelin innove dans son approche de services de la mobilité grâce à l’open innovation, au serious Game "Tech It ! " et avec les étudiants de GEM.

  •  Thibault Daudigeos is a researcher in Sustainability, Corporate Social Reponsibility, Alternative forms of Organization, Sharing economy, and new models of management at Grenoble Ecole de Management.
    Published on 26 January 2016

    Research: Corporate Social Responsibility at Odds with Global Markets?

    Corporate social responsibility (CSR) policies have received much attention for their potential to improve societal conditions while creating value for companies. However, this latest study from Grenoble Ecole de Management highlights the fact that...

  •  Thibault Daudigeos is a researcher in Sustainability, Corporate Social Reponsibility, Alternative forms of Organization, Sharing economy, and new models of management at Grenoble Ecole de Management.
    Published on 26 January 2016

    Recherche : Responsabilité sociale des entreprises globalisées, plus facile à dire qu’à faire

    Les démarches de Responsabilité sociale des entreprises (RSE) sont censées créer de la valeur. Pourtant, elles peinent à se mettre en place dans les secteurs où les chaînes de valeur sont éclatées : elles coûtent cher et ne profitent pas forcément à...

  • Published on 04 January 2016

    Recherche : Produit d’origine locale, une mention qui parle au consommateur

    La mention « origine locale » apposée sur un produit alimentaire déclenche chez le consommateur des perceptions plus positives et une intention d'achat plus forte qu'un produit d'une autre région française. Trois études portant sur 632 consommateurs...